Thank you jv16 for your responses to my concerns over RC1. I wanted to reply to some of your points. Full previous comments are in another thread:
http://www.macecraft.com/phpBB2/viewtopic.php?t=1934
1. Issue with running real-time AV:
You said: "Basically, many real-time antivirus products suck. For example, if a power tool, such as jv16 PowerTools scans the entire hard
disk......This can make the product to work very slow.
Another thing is when real-time antivirus scanner starts to analyze jv16
PowerTools itself....cause the program to start longer than normally....can cause the internal startup code of the PowerTools to crash and...can hang."
The problem is real-time AV scanning is here to stay. It's fair to say that major AV software programs have caused havoc for many other softwares. However, you must find a way to make jv16 2007 work stably, despite the possibilities you suggest. I don't remember any previous builds crashing or hanging because of real-time AV.
2. Interface overly complicated & configuring a chore:
You said: "Well, one can either add new features or not. If new features
aren't added the product seems obsolete and outdated, if new features are added there will be more functions (buttons, icons etc.) in the user
interface and some people can think that as the program getting
complicated."
The earlier products had a certain elegance & optimal functionality, a
nice balance. Features can be added/dropped/improved, that's cool, but it's the engine of each feature that's most important. Limit the configuration choices to a select important relative few. For example, I like to use the marking of history dates for Software & Registry entries, to easily see what has been added NEW to the registry, after installing a program, driver, etc.. So, it's important to be able to do that easily & quickly in the configuring interface. In the overall configuring sense...less is more.
3. The new registry cleaner engine, how well it works, info provided:
You said: "....new scanning module called the Leftover Software scanner which is able to find leftover registry entries and keys of uninstalled software...ability to detect entries which don't have any file or directory references.... list you the invalid or obsolete registry entries but also analyzes what happens if you remove these invalid items...it prints an organized list of the found registry errors, not the erroneous registry
entries and keys but the actual registry errors themselves. The list of
registry keys and entries is still available for advanced users, of course."
Those comments are well taken & impressive. You are creating the first reg cleaner to be able to do all that. However, this new engine detects a huge increase in the number of potential reg problems & more bogus ones, compared to your own past tools. In general, your tools have safely found & fixed more reg problems than any other software out there. To go from 50-200 problems to over 700 now detected is alarming. It's not necessary to list a bunch of entries for you here, as I see many others are reporing a similar find. With RC2, if list is still extensive, I'll send it in to you. You'll correct this, I sure, as I'm just reporting this RC1 experience. The scanning result dialog table of info needs to show critical reg error info first without scrolling all over for it & resizing everything constantly. Find a better layout. For all those reasons, I'm looking forward to testing RC2.
4. Thanks again jv for your original reg work over the years! :)