I had too much difficulty using Verify for Visa (it would not recognize my password, it refused to accept the answers to its questions about the hospital I was born in, etc.). I gave up on it.
Just call the toll-free number on the back of your credit or debit card, and tell the bank that you are sick of Verify for Visa, that it is more trouble than it is worth, and you want out. They can do this.
I did this, and a minute later I finished my Macecraft transaction, so it is possible to use the Macecraft online store without Verify for Visa (as it should be).